| Abide with Me | E♭ major | William Henry Monk | 1861 | C major · D♭ major · E♭ major · F major |
| Amazing Grace | G major | Traditional American melody (NEW BRITAIN) | 1779 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| Angels We Have Heard on High | F major | Traditional French | 1842 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| Auld Lang Syne | F major | Traditional Scottish melody | 1799 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| Away in a Manger | F major | James Ramsey Murray | 1887 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| Blessed Assurance | D major | Phoebe Palmer Knapp | 1873 | B major · C major · D major · E major |
| Come, Thou Fount of Every Blessing | D major | Anonymous American tune (NETTLETON) | 1813 | B major · C major · D major · E major |
| Deck the Halls | F major | Traditional Welsh (Nos Galan) | 1862 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| Good King Wenceslas | G major | Traditional (melody TEMPUS ADEST FLORIDUM, Piae Cantiones) | 1853 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| Happy Birthday to You | G major | Mildred J. Hill (melody of Good Morning to All) | 1893 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| Hark! The Herald Angels Sing | F major | Felix Mendelssohn | 1840 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear | B♭ major | Richard Storrs Willis | 1849 | G major · A♭ major · B♭ major · C major |
| It Is Well with My Soul | C major | Philip P. Bliss | 1876 | A major · B♭ major · C major · D major |
| Jingle Bells | G major | James Lord Pierpont | 1857 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| Joy to the World | D major | Lowell Mason (arranger) | 1836 | B major · C major · D major · E major |
| Nearer, My God, to Thee | G major | Lowell Mason | 1841 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| O Christmas Tree (O Tannenbaum) | G major | Traditional German folk melody | 1824 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| O Come, All Ye Faithful | G major | John Francis Wade (attributed) | 1751 | E major · F major · G major · A major |
| O Come, O Come, Emmanuel | E minor | Traditional (VENI EMMANUEL), adapted by Thomas Helmore | 1851 | C♯ minor · D minor · E minor · F♯ minor |
| O Holy Night | C major | Adolphe Adam | 1847 | A major · B♭ major · C major · D major |
| O Little Town of Bethlehem | F major | Lewis H. Redner | 1874 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| Rock of Ages | B♭ major | Thomas Hastings | 1831 | G major · A♭ major · B♭ major · C major |
| Silent Night | B♭ major | Franz Xaver Gruber | 1833 | G major · A♭ major · B♭ major · C major |
| The First Noel | D major | Traditional English | 1833 | B major · C major · D major · E major |
| We Three Kings | E minor | John Henry Hopkins Jr. | 1863 | C♯ minor · D minor · E minor · F♯ minor |
| What a Friend We Have in Jesus | F major | Charles Crozat Converse | 1865 | D major · E♭ major · F major · G major |
| What Child Is This? | E minor | Traditional English (GREENSLEEVES) | 1871 | C♯ minor · D minor · E minor · F♯ minor |